DR. KATHERINE S. CHO

  • Home
  • About
  • The Work
    • Research & Projects
    • Pedagogy & Teaching
    • Designs
  • Resources
    • "Me"-Sourced
    • "Out"-Sourced
    • Opportunities & Due Dates
    • Templates, Layouts
  • Reflections
  • Home
  • About
  • The Work
    • Research & Projects
    • Pedagogy & Teaching
    • Designs
  • Resources
    • "Me"-Sourced
    • "Out"-Sourced
    • Opportunities & Due Dates
    • Templates, Layouts
  • Reflections

Tips. Tidbits. Advice.

LESSONS LEARNED ALONGSIDE NAVIGATING THE ACADEMY (BLOG FORMAT)

Misleading journals & Publishers

4/3/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
Earlier last year, I got an inquiry from a journal and didn't think much of it. The email felt odd and I trust my instincts so I didn't reply back. (I also happened to be in the thick of data collection so didn't reply to many emails during that season). However, after sleuthing for my advisor on an email inquiry, I stumbled into the world of misleading and potentially predatory journals...
I just realized this sounds like the beginning of a science fiction novel or an Edgar Allan Poe story. Resemblance aside, the world of predatory journals and publishing companies, is not one that I knew until I started sleuthing.  (Note: some of the terms I use are based on prior knowledge regarding the publication process. If you are unfamiliar, read about it here). 

WHAT ARE THEY? 
(Potentially) fake/misleading/predatory journals or publishers can range from ones that are a little too ambiguous (e.g. lack of transparency about their editorial board or process) to ones that hold a manuscript "hostage" and demand/charge money for publication. Some journals and publishers might also encourage you to pay a small "fee" or "investment" as part of the review process.  In learning more about this, I have decided that for future, rare occasions of submission solicitation, I'll likely do a quick background search. 

HOW CAN YOU FIND OUT? 
There are several sites that you can look up if a journal or publishing company seems... a little off. A bulk of this work is from Jeffrey Beall, who is an American librarian and library scientist. Based on his work, here are some sites where you can search: 
  • ​Beall's List: which is a comprehensive list searchable both by publisher and by journal. (And yes, you are correct, this is the list Jeffrey Beall first created)
  • Stop Predatory Journals: which has some overlaps with Beall's list and also provides information about what makes a journal predatory and/or misleading
  • Yale University Library List of Suspicious Journals and Publishers: likewise includes overlap with the two resources above, but also provides additional information about copyright guidance, impact factors, and more

If you aren't able to scoop anything from the resources above, I recommend asking your mentors and peers (and maybe you should do that first anyways). During my own process, I looked for information about editorial boards, institutional affiliations, searched on these sites, and also looked on Twitter. Based on what you find, if you do think something is suspicious, I would add the tip and contact the above sites too so that they can update their databases.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Hopefully this doesn't detract you from publishing, but instead provides a cautionary tale. (Excuse me for my literary flairs).  And if you are curious about Beall's journey, I would highly recommend reading his first-person account that explained how he compiled the list and also the ways different publishers tried to get off these lists. You can access it here.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    ABOUT

    This page includes tips, advice, and ideas put together by yours truly (hence the "me"). For more, check out "OUT-SOURCED" for curated resources that I find helpful, or scroll down for my  WRITING BOOKSHELF. If you're looking for guides, check out TEMPLATES.

    Categories

    All
    Academia
    Design
    Last Day Digest
    Professional Development
    Writing


    Writing Books
    ​Bookshelf
    Writing is a craft. To sharpen mine, I read a fair amount of books, articles, excerpts, and more. At least for the books, here are some I've enjoyed. 

    And if you're looking to buy a book, support local bookstores, and/or buy via Bookshop.

    And if you want to support the content I create on this site, you can "buy me a cup of coffee" through the button. Thank you~
    Support thru coffeeGift A Cup

    Archives

    May 2025
    November 2024
    February 2023
    August 2022
    May 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    December 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    April 2017
    August 2016
    June 2016


Home

About

linktr.Ee

Photos from homegets.com, Artem Beliaikin, Homedust, Semtrio, shixart1985, blueprinthomes.com.au, davidstewartgets, wuestenigel, topten5, trydberg, verchmarco, Jessica L. Weiss, ralf.st, wuestenigel, Esparta, verchmarco, Semtrio, Gabriel GM, topten5, wuestenigel, homegets.com, trendingtopics, homegets.com, cartridgesaveimages, Semtrio, Ali Alcaide, Andrew Gustar, joabsmithphotography, davidstewartgets, wuestenigel, chimpwithcan, amtec_photos, ginomempin, Dmitry Fablov, topten5, davidstewartgets, Rawpixel Ltd, homegets.com, TLV and more, williamiwas, Rosmarie Voegtli, shixart1985, ThoroughlyReviewed, davidstewartgets, shixart1985